And its not even a gotcha question, his dogged commitment to misgendering litigants is arguably his most notable decision. Subscribe and get breaking news, commentary, and opinions on law firms, lawyers, law schools, lawsuits, judges, and more. The sweeping criminal investigation, which came to light earlier this week, alleges wealthy parents from different parts of the country sought out Newport Beach businessman William Singer with one overriding goal: to get their children into the best colleges. Video footage widely shared on social media shows that the school's associate dean of diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI), Tirien Steinbach, did nothing to quell the disruption as protesters hurled verbal abuse at the judge. But later, Stanford President Marc Tessier-Lavigne and Stanford Law Dean Jenny Martinez apologized to Duncan, saying that what happened was inconsistent with our policies on free speech., Without mentioning Steinbach by name, Tessier-Lavigne and Martinez said that staff members who should have enforced university policies failed to do so, and instead intervened in inappropriate ways.. Free Speech, Kyle Duncan, Law Schools, Stanford Law School, Stuart Kyle Duncan. He said he'll retract three of the papers and correct two. Two Stanford University students on Wednesday filed a federal class-action lawsuit against eight colleges ensnared in the largest college admissions scandal ever . Hed earlier called the protesters idiots., They are hypocrites and they are bullies, he said. Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes. Marc Tessier-Lavigne built one of the most stellar reputations in academia. All rights reserved. Fire Tirien Steinbach, the independent student paper the Stanford Review wrote on Twitter and as a headline to an op-ed on Sunday. As Christianity rises, China is preparing to flood its people with false scriptures, The limits of politics: What happens in your own home is what matters. For its part, the National Lawyers Guild said the student protesters represented Stanford Law School at its best.. Duncan recounted the experience in a WSJ op-ed on March 17, admitting that he was criticized by the media for his anger at the protestors, but refused to apologize for calling them appalling idiots, bullies and hypocrites because Sometimes anger is the proper response to vicious behavior., The most disturbing aspect of this shameful debacle is what it says about the state of legal education, he wrote. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact The students were particularly angry at Duncan for a 2020 opinion in which he refused to use a transgender sex offender's preferred pronouns. Incredibly, after the event, Steinbach told members of Stanfords Federalist Society that protesters complied with the schools free speech policy. Get all the stories you need-to-know from the most powerful name in news delivered first thing every morning to your inbox. Their actions were without a doubt insidious, selfish and shameful, FBI Special Agent Joseph Bonavolonta said Tuesday. She applied to USC in 2017 with stellar marks on her college entrance exams, paid the $85 application fee and was denied admission. Circuit Court Judge Kyle Duncan during his presentation at the school as an invited guest on March 9, 2023. After a hostile and profane Q&A session, he was escorted out the back door by federal marshals, who were there to protect him, the Free Beacon reported. Privacy Policy / The noisy incident captured on video spurred a backlash against Ms. Steinbach and student protesters over the lack of respect shown to the federal judge, who was invited to speak on campus by the Stanford Federalist Society. At the time she applied, Woods similarly was never informed that the process of admission at USC was an unfair, rigged process, in which parents could buy their way into the university through bribery and dishonest schemes, the lawsuit states. Circuit Court of Appeals, to talk about how the decisions of his court have affected Supreme Court decisions. Such a model relegates minority viewpoints to never being heard. In the meantime, the students of the Stanford Federalist Society should consider filingcomplaints with state bar examiners about the moral character of the protesters. Meantime, law firms will be spared from hiring new lawyers who lack the temperament and character to do the job well. In April, NCAA All-American swimmer Riley Gaines was chased down by protesters at San Francisco State University and protected in a room by campus police after she delivered remarks in opposition to male-born athletes competing in female athletic events. Stanford University has finally apologized to the Trump-appointed federal judge whose talk was hijacked by student protesters and a woke dean. We invited Megan Zavieh of Zavieh Law onto the Non-Eventcast to talk about modern legal ethics issues and provide us with real answers about how to handle them. This protest was a direct byproduct of what students have learned for years. A Rhodes Scholar who became a neuroscientist, he was credited with breakthrough research into the cause of Alzheimers disease. But the thing about free speech is I dont have to like it. Judge Ho said. Stanford Law official who admonished judge during speech is on leave This story has been shared 555,885 times. Tirien Steinbach, the Stanford University Law School associate dean of diversity, equity and inclusion, slams U.S. But this is hypocritical of them, since thats exactly what they are doing to their classmates in FedSoc.. Could Chinas Low Birthrate and Aging Population Weaken Its Ability as US Foe? Stanford diversity dean resigns after confronting Trump-backed judge at Striking hotel workers want her to stay away, How to find parking for the Taylor Swift Eras concerts at SoFi Stadium, Bear takes a dip in Burbank backyard as Californias heat wave continues, Tensions flare as California GOP gives Trump a boost by overhauling state primary rules, Los Padrinos Juvenile Hall in Downey remains on lockdown in aftermath of riot, Invasive fruit fly outbreak prompts agricultural quarantine in Santa Clarita Valley, L.A. County sheriffs recruit dies eight months after being struck by wrong-way driver in South Whittier. Obviously. pic.twitter.com/WkOIFpDEgx. Well, imagine that every judge who says theyre opposed to discrimination at Yale and Stanford takes the same path. Among the protesters' complaints was how Duncan refused to use a transgender sex offender's preferred pronouns in a 2020 opinion. Mutual Fund and ETF data provided by Refinitiv Lipper. His scientific work helped propel him to the position of president of Stanford University, where he excelled at raising money from Silicon Valley. He started heckling back and attacking student protestors. Private funds in-house and external legal teams are stretched thin by growing legal demands. Judge Duncan had an opportunity to inoculate himself against the damning quotes and video clips by just saying and I regret that my emotions got the better of me at a couple of points, implying that his actions were outliers and any clips of rowdy student behavior was the norm. : This midsize firm could be one of the first to have its own union! Have a confidential tip for our reporters? Tessier-Lavigne says he's stepping down because he expects continued debate about his ability to lead the university. Lat managed to get a response from Judge Duncan, who remained defiant in the face of his own clownish antics, explicitly noting, Did I speak sharply to some of the students? (Reuters) - Stanford Law School will not discipline students who disrupted a campus speech by a conservative federal judge earlier this month, but an official who appeared to intervene on the. ", STANFORD LAW PROTESTERS DEMAND TO HAVE NAMES REDACTED FROM NEWS REPORTS: NOT HOW THE FIRST AMENDMENT WORKS', Federal judges pledging not to hire Stanford students for clerkships. The students also claim that since Stanford is linked to the scandal, their degrees may be tainted. Discover below each of these unique places at the foot of . She wanted to placate students who said they were upset with Judge Duncan and to, I hoped, give the judge space to speak his prepared remarks. She noted, however, that she had been speaking to students in the room, and did not realize that her words would be blasted out to the world.. Is Wokeness Infecting the Military? I Walk The Line: Legal Ethics & The Impact Of Technology On Lawyer Burnout, Do not sell or share my personal information. GianCarlo Canaparo Sen. Ted Cruz, Texas Republican, led calls for Stanford to fire her and discipline the students. Well see if it lasts, but its a change for the better. Has Democracy Reached the End of Its History? This story has been shared 242,411 times. The message here is that its proper when the speech is already popular enough to draw a sizable crowd and can still thrive when shunted off to a quiet, out of the way location. Stanford Law Schools administration seems to think you can. In an email, Steinbach wrote that Duncan repeatedly and proudly threatened healthcare and basic rights for marginalized communities, including LGBTQ+ people, Native Americans, immigrants, prisoners, Black voters, and women., This isnt true, but an undeterred Steinbach said that his presence on campus represents a significant hit to [students] sense of belonging., Steinbach said Stanford Law School supports the right of students to protest the event, but she promised that the school would not censor Judge Duncans [sic], nor the students [sic] hosting him, nor stifle free speech by canceling this engagement.. Circuit court judges appointed by former President Trump plan to refuse hiring Stanford Law graduates following a scandal in which students verbally harassed a federal judge who was brought in as a guest speaker, according to a Saturday announcement. Listen: How student journalism uncovered a Stanford University scandal Two high profile Stanford administrators have just resigned. 1) by shouting down U.S. Maybe thats where we are going as a society, but that doesnt work in my courtroom.. The protest was spearheaded by the campus group OutLaw, which accused Duncan of threatening the rights of LGBTQ people, immigrants, black voters and women. Its supposed to be a BUT isnt it? Its time for rational people to stop pretending that the rules of polite society require them to tolerate this nonsense. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. "So what do we do about it?" Fox News' Chris Pandolfo contributed to this report. Impact of Hollywood strikes being felt across the pond, Israelis stage massive protests after government pushes through key reform, Ledecky breaks Phelps' record for most individual world titles, Ukraine moves Christmas to distance itself from Russian Orthodox Church, Mega Millions jackpot hits $1 billion mark, 4 killed, 2 hurt in separate aircraft accidents near Oshkosh, Wisconsin, World Cup athletes, family and colleagues remember Grant Wahl's legacy, Swift's "Eras" tour concerts cause seismic activity in Seattle, Escaped New Hampshire inmate shot and killed by police in Miami store. CRUZ CELEBRATES STANFORD PUNISHING DEAN WHO SHOUTED DOWN TRUMP-APPOINTED JUDGE: 'VICTORY FOR SANITY', The students reportedly called Duncan "scum," asked sexual questions and said, "We hope your daughters get raped.". Ever feel like the only difference between the New York Times and Washington Post is the name? My intention wasnt to confront Judge Duncan or the protesters but to give voice to the students so that they could stop shouting and engage in respectful dialogue., Duncan, who serves as a circuit judge for the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, was invited to speak at Stanford Law School by the Federalist Society on March 9 where he was met with angry protesters who held explicit posters that read FED SUCK and Trans Lives Matter and yelled insults like We hope your daughters get raped., Posters also accused Duncan of crimes against trans people for denying a pedophile prisoners request to changepronouns in 2020. And the real victims in the case are the hardworking students who did everything they could to set themselves up for success in the college admissions process, but ended up being shut out because far less qualified students and their families simply bought their way in.. Allen Stanford - Wikipedia Universities follow the money, Nolan Arenado to the Dodgers? That they should not be judged by the color of their skin OR by the content of their character? The organizations mission was to provide education that would normally be unattainable to underprivileged students, according to paperwork. At one point during the Q&A, Judge Duncan said, You are all law students. Indeed, this might be more dangerous than the overtly authoritarian notes sounded by others because policing speech draped in the rhetoric of reasonability uniquely silences the most vulnerable. When critics choose to protest rather than ask questions, its because YOU are smart and THEY are scared. Josh Blackman, an associate professor of law at theSouth Texas College of Law,explains that this arrogance is possible when a schools department of diversity, equity, and inclusion, or DEI, supports students victim mentality: When a university empowers DEI to deem speech harmful, DEI will deem speech harmful. When a university teaches students that harmful speech has no place on a campus, the students will take steps to prevent harmful speech on their campus. Fry most recently covered breaking news for The Times and was part of the team that was a 2020 Pulitzer finalist for its coverage of a boat fire that killed 34 people off the coast of Santa Barbara. Remember to include the URL or headline of the article plus your name and town and/or state. In the other two cases, the university said that the issues "do not affect the data, results or interpretation of the papers.". The president of Stanford University said Wednesday he would resign, citing an independent review that cleared him of research misconduct but found flaws in other papers authored by his lab. "We will not hire any student who chooses to attend Stanford Law School in the future," Judge Ho concluded. The story also mentioned several other papers of Tessier-Lavigne's, including two that he co-authored, that an outside expert said contained "serious problems." In fact, thats sort of the point. Mr. Tessier-Lavigne announced his resignation Wednesday amid concerns about integrity in his research. Copyright 2023 The Washington Times, LLC. That Tantrum at Stanford Law School and What to Do About It Federal judges pledging not to hire Stanford students for clerkships. Will Hollywood Learn From Disappointing Barbie Payoff for Pandering to China? To date, no protester, Stanford administrator, or defender of their actions has argued that any of Duncans rulings were legally wrong. A newly updated PLI treatise provides both the legal framework and practical guidance on documenting secured transactions, including important details about 2022 amendments to the UCC. The school apologized to him anyway. Perhaps the only thing uglier than the Stanford Law School building is the events that took place there on Thursday, the paper wrote, noting the hypocrisy of students angrily telling Duncan to stop interrupting Steinbach as she stopped his talk. Anonymous comments with racist, sexist and abusive messages that were posted for years on a jobs-related website for economists originated from numerous leading . Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. Stanford Law School Dean Jenny Martinez said she and Ms. Steinbach both hope that SLS can move forward as a community from the divisions caused by the March 9 event., The event presented significant challenges for the administration, the students and the entire law school community, Ms. Martinez said in a Thursday notice to students and faculty. For each of the handful of incidents where a speaker whines about a boisterous protest, there are scores more where nothing happens. As unpleasant as this was, Duncan said later that nobody should feel sorry for me. Instead, the judge said he felt bad and outraged for Federalist Society students who invited him. DIVERSITY DIRECTOR SAYS SHE WAS FIRED FROM CALIFORNIA COLLEGE FOR QUESTIONING ANTIRACISM 'ORTHODOXY', A skyline view of the Stanford campus in California. College admissions scandal fallout: Stanford students sue UCLA, USC and 1) by shouting down U.S. But Judge Stuart Kyle Duncan of the Fifth Circuit decided to challenge this foundational assumption when he rolled into Stanford Law School last week. Lessons about why free speech and rational debate are important to the practice of law will not work; these students are swept up in what they believe is a moral crusade. Heres How To Get Yours Right. Stanford recommitted strongly to free speech in the weeks that followed, said Alex Morey, the foundations director of campus rights advocacy. Finally, hiring managers at law firms should not hire any of those involved in such protests. Before the event started, about 100 protesters jeered at 20 or so members of The Federalist Society as they entered the room. First, Stanford should punish the students who protested and the administrators who did nothing. Student members of The Federalist Society invited Duncan, who sits on the 5th U.S. Try the Morning Bell and get the days most important news and commentary from a team committed to the truth in formats that respect your timeand your intelligence. In phone conversations with parents secretly recorded by agents, Singer boasted he had helped more than 850 students of the wealthy and powerful to lie their way into colleges in just two years. She applied to Yale in 2017 and paid an application fee of about $80, only to be rejected by the university, according to the lawsuit. And if you dont want to do that, then maybe these elite schools are not for you," he said. Stanford University in Palo Alto, California. Circuit Court Judge Kyle Duncan,. (Screenshot/ Vimeo - Ethics and Public Policy Center). To sound off, please emailletters@DailySignal.com, and well consider publishing your edited remarks in our regular We Hear You feature. Legal Statement. The protest was even larger than the one that occurred days earlier and came after the Stanford National Lawyers Guild said Martinez had thrown "capable and compassionate administrators" under the bus. Get all the stories you need-to-know from the most powerful name in news delivered first thing every morning to your inbox. The university's board of trustees said Richard Saller, a Stanford classics professor, would become interim president in September and that Tessier-Lavigne's resignation will take effect at . He asked the student to cite a case. WILL RAGOZZINO/Patrick McMullan via Getty Images, UFO hearing key takeaways: What a whistleblower told Congress about UAPs, U.S. passport demand continues to overwhelm State Department, Unlikely clue helps bring young mom's killer to justice, Heart attack or homicide? Federal Judge Calls Stanford Law Students 'Appalling Idiots' After Fox News' Emma Colton and Joe Silverstein contributed to this report. Tirien Steinbach, Stanford Law School's associate dean for diversity, equity and inclusion, resigned Thursday, months after her confrontation with Trump-appointed Judge Stuart Kyle Duncan went . Market data provided by Factset.